Smarter Travel recently posted a look at some of their favorite beaches in the world, and Holland America’s “Half Moon Cay” made it to the top of many reviewers lists.

The private island is 17 miles from its nearest neighbors and about 100 miles out of Nassau in the Bahamas. It is considered by many to be the most beautiful private island of any of the cruise lines offerings – and it’s easy to see why.

With a focus on swimming and water sports, a secluded location, and Holland America’s exclusivity – it’s no surprise that so many people find it an irresistible destination.